Serving St. Matthews, Louisville, KY and nearby neighborhoods

502-305-9910
TheArt of Coming Home

Allison Sherwin, REALTOR® with Rainey Allen Shaw

crescent hill

Crescent Hill Real Estate Agent

As a Crescent Hill real estate agent, I am based in St. Matthews, two miles east. I help owners sell and buyers find homes in Crescent Hill, Louisville. I price each one from nearby sales.

Allison Sherwin, Crescent Hill real estate agent in Louisville, seated and smiling

Crescent Hill homes in a Louisville historic district

Crescent Hill homes include the late 19th and early 20th century houses of the Crescent Hill Historic District. The National Park Service added the district to the National Register in 1982. Brownsboro and Lexington Roads, Peterson, Zorn, and Frankfort Avenues, and Crabbs Lane roughly bound it.

Its National Register record lists Colonial Revival and Classical Revival styles from 1875 to 1924. The 1982 nomination calls it a railroad suburb of Louisville, on gently rolling ground. Institutions on large grounds sit among the houses.

Building began in the 1850s. That is when the turnpike now called Frankfort Avenue and the railroad came through.

Map: Crescent Hill is 2.0 miles straight-line from my officeSchematic map: Crescent Hill 2.0 miles in a straight line from my office at 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103, highlighted, with distance rings at 1 to 5 miles. Around Crescent Hill, the other places and their straight-line miles are: St. Matthews 0.7, Windy Hills 1.0, Cherokee Gardens 2.2, Indian Hills 2.5, Hurstbourne 3.2, The Highlands 4.6. River and interstate lines: OpenStreetMap.N1 mi2 mi3 mi4 mi5 miI-64I-71I-264Ohio RiverMy officeCrescent Hill2.0 miSt. Matthews0.7 miWindy Hills1.0 miCherokee Gardens2.2 miIndian Hills2.5 miHurstbourne3.2 miThe Highlands4.6 miMy office: 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103Miles are straight-line from my office.Rings mark each mile.Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors
On a ridge between two forks of Beargrass Creek, the neighborhood is 2.0 straight-line miles west of my office.

Selling or buying in the Crescent Hill Historic District?

Tell me the street and the year the house was built. I will send the selling or buying guide you need and follow up personally.

Crescent Hill real estate values in Census figures

Crescent Hill real estate values in Census figures run from $275,000 to $610,500, by census tract. The Census Bureau publishes no figure for the neighborhood itself. The table shows the five tracts that cover it.

Census tract Share of area Median owner-occupied home value (±) Housing units
77 37% $489,900 (± $59,040) 983
78 17% $363,400 (± $33,362) 1,658
76.01 16% $275,000 (± $121,361) 1,073
79 16% $390,800 (± $39,248) 970
87 14% $610,500 (± $34,870) 1,535

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, the five tracts, ACS 2020-2024 5-year estimates, read 11 November 2026. Other columns cover whole tracts; tract 87 reaches beyond the neighborhood. Jefferson County’s median is $248,400 (± $2,496).

These are survey estimates, not sale prices. I price a home here from sold homes nearby, active listings, and its condition. You can read my listing steps for a Crescent Hill seller, with the usual timing of each.

Owning a home in Crescent Hill: Metro services and design review

Owning a home in Crescent Hill puts you in Louisville Metro’s Urban Services District. That is the old City of Louisville. The county’s LOJIC map shows the whole neighborhood inside it. Metro collects the garbage and provides the carts free.

A National Register listing puts no federal limits on a private owner. The National Park Service says so. That changes only when a project uses federal money or a federal permit.

This neighborhood is not on Metro’s list of eight local preservation districts. It is not in one of the three design overlay districts either.

Outside work needs no Certificate of Appropriateness. An individual landmark is the one exception. Ask Metro’s Office of Planning to confirm your address before you plan.

Taking a house down is different.

Any building 50 years or older gets a historic review before Metro issues a wrecking permit. If Landmarks staff find it significant, demolition waits 30 days.

Selling a Crescent Hill home built before 1978

Selling a Crescent Hill home built before 1978 brings a federal lead paint rule. Before your buyer signs, you give them the EPA’s lead pamphlet. You also disclose any lead paint you know about. The buyer then gets 10 days to test for lead, or a time you both agree to in writing.

As your real estate agent, I ask for receipts and permits for major work. I also ask for your notes on the roof, heating and air, and windows. Receipts and notes help your price hold at the inspection and appraisal. If the house came to you through an estate, see how I sell an inherited Crescent Hill home.

Thinking about selling here?

Tell me which census tract your house is in and when you want to list. I will send my Home Selling Guide.

Small updates first.

Small updates like paint, lighting, and a clean entry often return more than big renovations. At our walk-through, I will go through your projects with you.

My free videos with color and layout ideas show what a room could become before you spend a dollar. Each one starts with a real room as it stands today.

Buying a home in Crescent Hill: what to check

Buying a home in Crescent Hill starts with a lender, for a pre-approval. Showings come next. Then I set MLS alerts for Crescent Hill homes for sale that fit your needs.

I bring the seller’s disclosure and nearby comparable sales to each showing. I explain every document before you sign it. That is one of my five promises to every Crescent Hill client. Open closets and cabinets, and check water pressure, outlets, and windows.

If the house was built before 1978, use your 10-day window. Hire a certified inspector to test for lead.

As your real estate agent, I attend the home inspection with you. We review the full report together. If you plan to replace the house, allow for the demolition review above. This is how I guide a Crescent Hill buyer from pre-approval to keys.

Looking for a home in Crescent Hill?

Ask for my Home Buying Guide, from the first showing to the keys.

Crescent Hill, Louisville: landmarks and the drive from my office

From my office, the drive to the Peterson-Dumesnil House, a Crescent Hill landmark in Louisville, is 3.3 miles. The neighborhood sits on a ridge between two forks of Beargrass Creek, about four miles east of downtown Louisville. Frankfort Avenue runs through the middle.

The neighborhood reaches from North Ewing Avenue east to the St. Matthews line near Cannons Lane. It also runs from Brownsboro Road to Lexington Road.

Landmark What the sources say
Crescent Hill Reservoir Louisville Water Company’s reservoir has been on the National Register since 1979. Its High Victorian Gothic gatehouse was renovated inside and out in 2013.
Water treatment plant The company’s plant stands between Stilz Avenue and Sacred Heart Lane.
Peterson-Dumesnil House The house is on South Peterson Avenue. It is on the National Register too.

As your Crescent Hill real estate agent, I work from an office 2.0 miles from the neighborhood. That distance is in a straight line.

Directions

Getting to my office from the Peterson-Dumesnil House on South Peterson Avenue

  1. Leave the house grounds and follow South Galt Avenue for about 0.3 mile.
  2. Turn right onto Frankfort Avenue (US 60), past Louisville Fire Department Engine 4, and stay on it for 2.2 miles.
  3. Frankfort Avenue becomes Shelbyville Road. Follow it 0.2 mile.
  4. Turn left onto St. Matthews Avenue and go 0.15 mile.
  5. Turn right onto Westport Road (KY 1447) and follow it 0.4 mile.
  6. Turn right into the office lot at 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103.
Measure Crescent Hill to my office
Start of the drive Peterson-Dumesnil House
Straight line, from the middle 2.0 miles
Drive 3.3 miles
Drive time 8 minutes, an OSRM estimate

good questions

Questions about a Crescent Hill real estate agent

Is Crescent Hill a historic district in Louisville?

The Crescent Hill Historic District has been on the National Register since 1982. Metro does not list it as a local preservation district. Only an individual landmark needs a Certificate of Appropriateness for outside work. Ask Metro about your address.

Can I tear down an older house in Crescent Hill?

You need a Louisville Metro wrecking permit. For a building 50 years or older, Metro’s Historic Preservation Officer and Landmarks staff review the request. If they find it significant, demolition waits 30 days.

Is Crescent Hill inside the old City of Louisville?

Yes. It sits inside Louisville Metro’s Urban Services District. That district follows the old City of Louisville boundary. Metro’s Solid Waste Management Services Division collects the garbage and provides the carts free.

How do you price a home in Crescent Hill?

I start with sold homes nearby, then add active listings and your home’s condition. Census tract medians here run from $275,000 to $610,500, so a neighborhood average will not price your house.

How far is Crescent Hill from your office?

My office on Westport Road is 2.0 miles in a straight line from the middle of the neighborhood. From the Peterson-Dumesnil House to my office it is 3.3 miles by road. The OSRM route planner estimates 8 minutes.

Can I read reviews before I call you?

Yes, on my reviews page. Reviews there appear as written, beside a first name and last initial. The page also explains how to leave your own. Before you call, read my reviews as you choose a Crescent Hill agent.

CallFree guide