Serving St. Matthews, Louisville, KY and nearby neighborhoods

502-305-9910
TheArt of Coming Home

Allison Sherwin, REALTOR® with Rainey Allen Shaw

the highlands

Highlands Real Estate Agent in Louisville

As a Highlands real estate agent, I work in this area of six Louisville neighborhoods. My St. Matthews base for Highlands clients is 4.6 miles from the area’s center. Half the homes in ZIP 40204, at that center, date to 1939 or earlier. I set each price from recent sales nearby.

Allison Sherwin, Highlands real estate agent, seated and smiling

The Highlands neighborhoods in Louisville, Kentucky

The Highlands neighborhoods sit on a ridge in Louisville, Kentucky. The area has no single official boundary. Its spine is a three-mile stretch of Bardstown Road and Baxter Avenue.

On this page, the name means six neighborhoods on Louisville Metro’s LOJIC map. The table of home values below lists all six.

The area is part of Louisville, not a separate city. Louisville Metro’s Office of Planning runs its design review.

Map: The Highlands is 4.6 miles straight-line from my officeSchematic map: The Highlands 4.6 miles in a straight line from my office at 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103, highlighted, with distance rings at 1 to 5 miles. Around The Highlands, the other places and their straight-line miles are: St. Matthews 0.7, Windy Hills 1.0, Crescent Hill 2.0, Cherokee Gardens 2.2, Indian Hills 2.5, Hurstbourne 3.2. River and interstate lines: OpenStreetMap.N1 mi2 mi3 mi4 mi5 miI-64I-71I-264Ohio RiverMy officeThe Highlands4.6 miSt. Matthews0.7 miWindy Hills1.0 miCrescent Hill2.0 miCherokee Gardens2.2 miIndian Hills2.5 miHurstbourne3.2 miMy office: 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103Miles are straight-line from my office.Rings mark each mile.Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors
The area’s center, in ZIP 40204, is 4.6 miles from my office in a straight line.

Highlands homes for sale: Victorian, shotgun and revival houses

Among homes for sale in the Highlands, older Victorian and revival houses are common. Some streets also have shotgun houses.

The National Register of Historic Places lists two districts here. The Highlands Historic District was added in 1983. The Cherokee Triangle Area Residential District was added in 1976.

Cherokee Triangle is mostly single-family homes. It also has some apartments in larger buildings and converted houses.

ZIP 40204, at the center Census estimate
Housing units 8,818
Built in 1939 or earlier Half of the homes

Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey. The figures are its 2020-2024 5-year estimates.

Own a home here and thinking of selling?

Ask for my free Home Selling Guide. Call me to talk about your Highlands street.

Highlands home values, neighborhood by neighborhood

Highlands home values change a great deal between neighborhoods. Tract medians for owner-occupied homes run from $301,900 to $679,200.

Neighborhood Census tract Median value, owner-occupied homes Miles from my office (straight line)
Original Highlands 64 $301,900 ± $54,709 4.6
Cherokee Triangle 82.02 and 82.01 $589,400 ± $60,052 and $679,200 ± $87,225 3.9
Bonnycastle 85 $410,200 ± $62,273 3.4
Highlands-Douglass 88 $486,100 ± $59,367 3.0
Belknap 89 $429,400 ± $17,818 3.8
Deer Park 84 $345,300 ± $37,536 3.9

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates, table B25077. These are survey estimates with their margins of error, not sale prices. Jefferson County’s median on the same survey is $248,400 ± $2,496.

Each row uses the tract that covers most of the neighborhood on LOJIC’s map. Tracts and neighborhoods do not line up exactly.

As your real estate agent, I look at three things to price your own Highlands home. Sold homes nearby over the last several months show what buyers have actually paid. Active listings are your competition today. Then I weigh your home’s condition and what sets it apart.

Cherokee Triangle real estate and its preservation district

Cherokee Triangle real estate sits inside one of Louisville Metro’s eight local preservation districts. This one was designated in 1975. The district lies east of Baxter Avenue and Bardstown Road.

Cave Hill Cemetery bounds it on the north. Cherokee Park bounds it on the east. The park covers 409 acres. Frederick Law Olmsted designed it in 1891.

Design review

Outside changes, demolition, and new construction in the district go through design review. Depending on the scope, work on the outside needs a Certificate of Appropriateness.

City staff or the Cherokee Triangle Architectural Review Committee approves the certificate. Louisville Metro’s district page has the guidelines, the application, and an address lookup.

Many properties here are also on the National Register. A listed property may qualify for historic rehabilitation tax credits. The Kentucky Heritage Council runs them. Ask your accountant whether they fit your project.

The Bardstown Road corridor overlay in the Highlands

The Bardstown Road corridor overlay in the Highlands is called the BROD. It was set up in 1990 for Bardstown Road and Baxter Avenue. Inside it, outside changes usually need an Overlay Permit. The Urban Design Administrator or the BROD Committee approves each application.

Selling a Highlands home: records, repairs and price

Selling a Highlands home goes better with its records in hand. As your listing agent, I will ask for the receipts and permits for major work. For a Victorian or revival house, write down when the roof, heating and air, water heater, and windows were updated. I ask for these early in my steps to list a Highlands home.

Records help your price

Records of repairs and honest answers help your price hold up at inspection and appraisal. Most housing built before 1978 needs a federal lead-based paint disclosure, under an EPA rule.

In Cherokee Triangle, keep any past Certificate of Appropriateness with those papers. At the walk-through, I will say which projects pay off and which do not. Paint, lighting, and a clean entry often return more than a big renovation. Before you pay for any project, see what virtual staging could show in a Highlands room.

Preparing takes about 1 to 3 weeks in my plan. That is an estimate, not a promise.

Ready to list your home here?

Read my reviews, and how to leave one, before our Highlands walk-through. Then ask for my free Home Selling Guide. I follow up personally.

Buying in the Highlands: checking an older house and its street

Buying here means checking an older house and the rules on its street. As your real estate agent, I start with your pre-approval letter. Next, we begin touring homes in the area. My full order of steps is in the buyer stages I follow on a Highlands offer.

At each showing, I bring the seller’s disclosure and nearby comparable sales. Open the closets, run the water, and try the outlets and windows. Planning to change the outside? Ask first if the address needs design review approval.

Where the address sits Outside work may need Approved by
In the Cherokee Triangle preservation district A Certificate of Appropriateness City staff or its Architectural Review Committee
In the Bardstown Road corridor overlay An Overlay Permit Urban Design Administrator or BROD Committee

On inspections, you and I read the full report together while the inspection contingency is still in place. If the appraisal comes in low, we have options. If you are buying from another city, see my help with a move to the Highlands.

Thinking of buying here?

Ask for my free Home Buying Guide. Call me before you book a showing.

A Highlands real estate agent based in St. Matthews

As a Highlands real estate agent, I work from my office in St. Matthews. The address is 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103, Louisville, 4.6 miles in a straight line from the area’s center. From Cherokee Park, about 2.1 miles of the drive runs along Lexington Road.

Directions

Getting to my office from Cherokee Park

  1. From Scenic Loop in Cherokee Park, turn right onto Cochran Hill Road.
  2. Turn right onto Lexington Road and follow it for about 2.1 miles.
  3. Pass the Our Honored Dead memorial on your left, then continue straight onto Frankfort Avenue, which becomes Shelbyville Road.
  4. Turn left onto St. Matthews Avenue.
  5. Turn right onto Westport Road. After about 0.4 mile, turn right into 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103.
Measure The Highlands to my office
Start of the drive Scenic Loop in Cherokee Park
Straight line, from the area’s center 4.6 miles
Drive, by OpenStreetMap routing, November 2026 About 3.4 miles
Stretch on Lexington Road About 2.1 miles

good questions

Questions to ask a Highlands real estate agent

Which neighborhoods make up the Highlands?

The area has no single official boundary. On this page it means six neighborhoods on Louisville Metro’s LOJIC map. They are Original Highlands, Cherokee Triangle, Bonnycastle, Belknap, Deer Park, and Highlands-Douglass. My background and approach for Highlands clients are on my About page.

Do I need city approval to change the outside of my home here?

Sometimes. In the Cherokee Triangle district, outside work may need a Certificate of Appropriateness. On the Bardstown Road and Baxter Avenue corridor, outside changes usually need an Overlay Permit. Check your address on LOJIC Online first.

How much is a house in the Highlands worth?

It depends on the neighborhood. Owner-occupied tract medians run from $301,900 to $679,200 across the six neighborhoods (ACS 2020-2024). As a real estate agent, I price your home from sold homes nearby, active listings, and condition.

Are Highlands homes on the National Register of Historic Places?

Many properties are, because they sit in two historic districts. The National Register lists the Highlands Historic District (1983). It also lists the Cherokee Triangle Area Residential District (1976). Check your address on LOJIC Online.

How far is your office from the Highlands?

My office is at 4156 Westport Rd, Ste 103, Louisville, in the St. Matthews area. It is 4.6 miles in a straight line from the area’s center. From Cherokee Park, the drive is about 3.4 miles, mostly on Lexington Road.

What should I check before buying an older Highlands home?

Start with your pre-approval. At each showing, test the water pressure, outlets, and windows. Read the seller’s disclosure. Then check whether your outside plans need Cherokee Triangle or Bardstown Road design review.

CallFree guide